Ventilation Continues to be a Big Concern in Ontario Schools

The SickKids’ report entitled, “COVID-19: Guidance for School Reopening”  was first released on June 17, 2020. Fix Our Schools noted with interest that ventilation was cited as an important element of a safe return to school, and so began to ask citizens to submit concerns about ventilation in their local schools.

We have heard from dozens of parents, educators and education workers across the province with a myriad of issues pertaining to ventilation, including classrooms without windows, windows that do not open at all or that only open a tiny bit, and some older schools and portables without HVAC systems to bring in fresh air from outside, and have presented details in the table below.

We urge you to contact your local MPP (we’ve provided emails below) and also Premier Ford (premier@ontario.ca) and Minister Lecce (stephen.lecce@pc.ola.org) to voice your concerns about ventilation in your local schools, and to urge this provincial government to provide the funding actually needed for publicly funded schools to open their doors safely in a few short weeks.

School Board Ventilation Issue MPP Riding Party
Tom Thomson School HDSB Classrooms with windows only at ceiling
Windows do not open
Some shared spaces with no windows
Hon. Jane McKenna
email: jane.mckenna@pc.ola.org
Burlington PC
Mohawk Gardens Public School HDSB Most classrooms without windows
Some classrooms with tiny windows up high
Hon. Jane McKenna
email: jane.mckenna@pc.ola.org
Burlington PC
Central Public School HDSB Poor ventilation Hon. Jane McKenna
email: jane.mckenna@pc.ola.org
Burlington PC
John T. Tuck Public School HDSB Windows on top floor barely open
Office spaces with no windows
Hon. Jane McKenna
email: jane.mckenna@pc.ola.org
Burlington PC
Tait St. Public School WRDSB Windows don’t fully open Hon. Belinda C. Karahalios
email: belinda.karahalios@pc.ola.org
Cambridge PC
Kars on the Rideau Public School OCDSB Poor ventilation
Poor air circulation
Air has a musty smell
Hon. Goldie Ghamari
email: goldie.ghamari@pc.ola.org
Carleton PC
Mount Hope School HWDSB Upper level windows do not open
Lower level windows barely open
Hon. Donna Skelly
email: donna.skelly@pc.ola.org
Flamborough-Glanbrook PC
Earl of March Secondary School OCDSB Interior classrooms without windows
Poor ventilation system
Hon. Merrilee Fullerton
email: merrilee.fullerton@pc.ola.org
Kanata—Carleton PC
Kemptville Public School UCDSB Brand new building has windows that don’t open and class with no window at all Hon. Steve Clark
email: steve.clark@pc.ola.org
Leeds—Grenville—Thousand Islands and Rideau Lakes PC
Harry Bowes PS YRDSB Windows barely open
Poor air circulation
Hon. Paul Calandra
email: paul.calandra@pc.ola.org
Markham—Stouffville PC
Randall Public School YRDSB Kindergarten class windows won’t open Hon. Logan Kanapathi
email: logan.kanapathi@pc.ola.org
Markham—Thornhill PC
Forest Glen Public School PDSB Windows barely open Hon. Kaleed Rasheed
email: kaleed.rasheed@pc.ola.org
Mississauga East—Cooksville PC
Gladys Speers Public School HDSB Windows that don’t open
Windows that barely open
Hon. Stephen Crawford
email: stephen.crawford@pc.ola.org
Oakville PC
Center Wellington District High School UGDSB Windows don’t open
A/C functions poorly, or is not turned on
Classrooms on 3rd floor reach 40°C
Hon. Ted Arnott
email: ted.arnott@pc.ola.org
Wellington-Halton Hills PC
Crescent Town School TDSB Five classrooms with no windows Hon. Rima Berns-McGown
email: RBerns-McGown-QP@ndp.on.ca
Beaches—East York NDP
Gledhill Junior Public School TDSB No ventilation
Classroom sink doesn’t work
Hon. Rima Berns-McGown
email: RBerns-McGown-QP@ndp.on.ca
Beaches—East York NDP
D A Morrison Middle School TDSB Air system does not move air well around building: poor heathing & cooling
NONE of the classrooms have windows that open.
Changes to building (from open concept) lead to poor air circulation
Hon. Rima Berns-McGown
email: RBerns-McGown-QP@ndp.on.ca
Beaches—East York NDP
St. Thomas Aquinas Secondary School DPCDSB Windows only open 3-4 inches
There are only 2 windows per classroom
Many rooms do not have screens
HVAC malfunctions
Hon. Gurratan Singh
email: GSingh-QP@ndp.on.ca
Brampton East NDP
École secondaire Toronto Ouest (shares building with Saint-Frère-André) CSViamonde Classrooms without windows
A/C is ancient, not working
Sewage system malfunctions
Hon. Marit Stiles
email: MStiles-QP@ndp.on.ca
Davenport NDP
École secondaire catholique Saint-Frère-André CSC MonAvenir No classrooms with windows
A/C is ancient, not working
Sewage system malfunctions
Hon. Marit Stiles
email: MStiles-QP@ndp.on.ca
Davenport NDP
Regal Road Public School TDSB No screens
Windows on south side need replacing
Windows that don’t open
Hon. Marit Stiles
email: MStiles-QP@ndp.on.ca
Davenport NDP
Westdale Secondary School HWDSB Windows barely open, or not at all
Year round, building has extreme temperatures
Hon. Sandy Shaw
email: SShaw-CO@ndp.on.ca
Hamilton NDP
Yorkview Elementary School HWDSB Extreme heat, poor air flow in classrooms and no air conditioning Hon. Sandy Shaw
SShaw-CO@ndp.on.ca
Hamilton NDP
Dundana Elementary School HWDSB Extreme heat, poor air flow in classrooms and no air conditioning Hon. Sandy Shaw
SShaw-CO@ndp.on.ca
Hamilton NDP
Memorial City Elementary School HWDSB Dust coming out of the ventilation system
Windows difficult to open
Windows barely open (3 inches)
Hon. Andrea Horwath
email: horwatha-qp@ndp.on.ca
Hamilton Centre NDP
Parkdale School HWDSB Some windows don’t open Hon. Paul Miller
email: pmiller-qp@ndp.on.ca
Hamilton East – Stoney Creek NDP
Kingston Collegiate & Vocational Institute LDSB Windowless classrooms
Windows that don’t have the mechanisms to remain propped open
Students moving this winter to a new school that doesn’t have windows that open
Hon. Ian Arthur
email: IArthur-QP@ndp.on.ca
Kingston and the Islands NDP
St. John Catholic Elementary WCDSB Basement classrooms with windows that don’t open
Poor ventilation system
Hon. Laura Mae Lindo
email: LLindo-QP@ndp.on.ca
Kitchener Centre NDP
Clarke Road Secondary School TVDSB Classrooms with no windows
Hall windows are screwed shut
Hon. Teresa J. Armstrong
email: tarmstrong-qp@ndp.on.ca
London—Fanshawe NDP
Humberside Public School TDSB Windows barely open
Windows require textbooks to prop open
Unbearably hot year round
School has no fans
Hon. Bhutila Karpoche
email: BKarpoche-QP@ndp.on.ca
Parkdale-High Park NDP
Western Technical Commercial School TDSB Windows have broken frames & cranks Hon. Bhutila Karpoche
email: BKarpoche-QP@ndp.on.ca
Parkdale-High Park NDP
Island Public school TDSB Classrooms with no windows Hon. Chris Glover
email: CGlover-CO@ndp.on.ca
Spadina—Fort York NDP
École Élémentaire Immaculée Conception CSC MonAvenir Old building, poor ventilation
Shared with another school
Hon. Jennifer Stevens
email: JStevens-QP@ndp.on.ca
St. Catharines NDP
Holy Trinity Catholic Elementary School SCDSB Kindergarten class with no windows Hon. Jamie West
email: JWest-QP@ndp.on.ca
Sudbury NDP
Lo-Ellen Park Secondary School RDSB Classrooms with one small window that barely open
Science classroom with tiny window, no venting
Hon. Jamie West
email: JWest-QP@ndp.on.ca
Sudbury NDP
Winchester Public School TDSB Half of school building has ancient windows Hon. Suze Morrison
email: SMorrison-QP@ndp.on.ca
Toronto Centre NDP
Roden P.S. TDSB Windows that do not open Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
Equinox Alternative School TDSB Windows that do not open Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
Holy Name Catholic School TCDSB Old windows with faulty mechanisms
Radiators, not enough ventilation
Stops on windows mean they only open 2-3″
Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
RH McGregor Elementary School TDSB No windows that open in entire school
School is open concept with no walls
School is attached to a medical building
Roof leaks
Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
Duke of a Connaught Public School TDSB The windows barely open (open diagonally to about 30 degrees)
Unbearable heat year round
Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
Bruce Public School TDSB Windows barely open Hon. Peter Tabuns
email: tabunsp-qp@ndp.on.ca
Toronto—Danforth NDP
York Humber High School TDSB Windows are locked closed
HVAC constantly breaking down
Hon. Faisal Hassan
email: FHassan-QP@ndp.on.ca
York South—Weston NDP
St. Anselm Catholic School TCDSB Old windows with faulty mechanisms
Radiators, not enough ventilation
Hon. Kathleen O. Wynne
email: kwynne.mpp.co@liberal.ola.org
Don Valley West LIBERAL
Carson Grove Elementary School OCDSB Windows don’t open
Some classrooms have no windows
Hon. Lucille Collard
email: LCollard.mpp.co@liberal.ola.org
Ottawa-Vanier LIBERAL
Ecole Gron Morgan Public School LDSB Poor ventilation
Extreme temperatures during winter
Hon. Michael Gravelle
email: mgravelle.mpp.co@liberal.ola.org
Thunder Bay—Superior North LIBERAL
Duncan J Schoular Public School UCDSB Design for school was to have a/c installed, so few windows, no real ventilation Hon. Randy Hillier
email: RHillier-CO@ola.org
Lanark—Frontenac—Kingston INDEPENDENT

Comments and issues presented in the table above have been submitted to Fix Our Schools from citizens, and have not been verified by Fix Our Schools.

In an August 15, 2020, Toronto Star article by May Warren entitled, “What you need to know about ventilation as Ontario prepares for back to school in the age of COVID-19“, Jeffrey Siegel, a professor of civil engineering at the University of Toronto states that “ventilation is all about bringing outdoor air in” but that people frequently confuse ventilation with filtration, which removes particles from the air that may contain COVID-19. Siegel notes that ventilation is much more important than filtration in reducing the spread of COVID-19, and that outdoor spaces seem to be the safest place to be, relative to COVID-19. One temporary solution for Ontario’s return to school plan would be to hold outdoor classes where possible. 

Seigel also raises the important point that HVAC systems in Ontario’s schools have been neglected for decades and require ongoing investments in order to be there when we need them the most – as in the case of a global pandemic! Premier Ford and all future provincial governments – please take note! Ongoing regular maintenance to ensure our infrastructure is in good working order is not a “nice to have” – it is a fiscal and health imperative.

In the same Toronto Star article, Fix Our Schools responded to Education Minister Lecce’s new allocation of $50-M for HVAC improvements in Ontario’s schools by saying this investment was “too little too late”. Krista Wylie, co-founder of Fix Our Schools noted that this investment only amounts to roughly $10,000 per school and that there were only a few weeks until schools are to reopen, leaving many classrooms in the position of likely being poorly ventilated this September.

Finally, the August 15 Toronto Star Article provides some vivid visuals about what bad, good and best classroom ventilation/airflow scenarios would look like, so be sure to check in with your children, teachers and education workers to find out what the scenario is like in their environment, once classes resume. Depending on what you discover, contact your local MPP and also Premier Ford (premier@ontario.ca) and Minister Lecce (stephen.lecce@pc.ola.org) to voice your concerns and urge this provincial government to provide the funding actually needed for schools to be the safe, healthy, well-maintained buildings that they ought to be.

Classroom airflow scenarios

Bad

Either windows don’t open or there are no windows so no fresh air is coming in. The heating ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) system is not working, or hasn’t been adjusted to bring in more outside air. There may be no HVAC system.

Better

Opening windows is ideal to get air flowing. If there are no windows, you can bring in portable air filters. HVAC systems, if they exist, should be adjusted to increase fresh airflow and reduce re-circulation. Filters should be changed frequently. Desks should be spaced 2 metres apart.

Best

If possible, classes could be held outside in the fresh air.

MCKENNA DEIGHTON